Build to Rent vs Buy to Let: What Newcomers Should Know

In Canada’s fast-evolving rental market, investors face a key decision: Build to Rent vs Buy to Let. While Build to Rent offers long-term stability through purpose-built rental communities, Buy to Let remains a popular choice for hands-on investors seeking higher yields. This guide breaks down the differences, benefits, and risks of each model helping you make smarter property investment decisions in the Canadian landscape.

• How to Build a Rental Portfolio: A Step-by-Step Guide for Investors
• BTR vs Coliving: Understanding Modern Housing Models
• Real Estate Investment: Understanding the Market and Effective Strategies

What is Build to Rent?

Build to Rent (BTR) refers to purpose-built residential properties specifically designed and constructed for long-term rental occupancy rather than for sale. These developments are typically owned by large institutional investors, such as pension funds, real estate investment trusts (REITs), or development firms, which provide the financial strength and scale needed to manage these communities effectively.

BTR properties are professionally managed with dedicated on-site teams responsible for maintenance, tenant relations, and community engagement. They often include a range of built-in amenities such as gyms, co-working spaces, communal lounges, rooftop terraces, and secure parking. The goal is to create a lifestyle-oriented rental experience that fosters a sense of community and convenience, appealing to renters who seek quality, flexibility, and services that go beyond traditional rental housing.

Because BTR developments are designed from the ground up for renters, they often feature modern layouts, smart home technology, and sustainable building practices. This model benefits tenants by offering a hassle-free renting experience with transparent lease terms, while investors gain from steady rental income and long-term asset appreciation.

What is Buy to Let?

Buy to Let (BTL) is a traditional investment strategy where individuals or small investors purchase residential properties with the intention of renting them out to tenants to generate rental income and potentially benefit from capital growth over time. Unlike Build to Rent, Buy to Let investors usually own one or a few properties and are responsible for managing their investments, either personally or through letting agents.

Buy to Let investors face a more hands-on approach, including finding tenants, handling maintenance issues, managing rent collection, and complying with landlord regulations. Many choose to outsource these tasks to property management companies, but the investor retains ultimate control and responsibility.

The Buy to Let market is often influenced by local housing demand, mortgage availability, tax policies, and regulatory changes. Investors typically focus on factors like rental yield, location, and property condition to maximize returns. While Buy to Let offers flexibility and potential profitability, it also carries risks such as tenant turnover, vacancy periods, and maintenance costs.

Key Differences Between Build to Rent and Buy to Let

Additional Insights

• Financial Returns: While BTR offers stable income, Buy to Let returns can be higher but come with increased management effort and risk. For example, in Canadian markets, rental yields vary significantly by location, with more affordable cities offering better ROI but potentially slower capital growth.
• Tenant Demand: BTR developments cater to lifestyle-oriented renters seeking amenities and community, which can reduce vacancy rates. Buy to Let tenants often have more varied experiences depending on landlord quality and property features.
• Regulatory Environment: Institutional investors in BTR benefit from streamlined regulations, while Buy to Let landlords must navigate a patchwork of local rules, taxes, and restrictions, especially affecting foreign buyers.

Real Estate Landscape in Canada 

Demand & Housing Shortages

• Rental demand in Canada is currently at an all-time high, primarily driven by strong immigration and a limited supply of rental housing. The influx of newcomers, many settling in major urban centers like Toronto, Vancouver, and Montreal, has intensified competition for rental units. This has led to rapid rent increases, making affordability a growing concern for many renters.
• Recent data shows a significant month-over-month increase in rental demand across Canada’s top markets. For example, March 2025 saw a nearly 30% rise in demand compared to February, signaling a strong leasing season ahead. However, year-over-year figures indicate that while short-term demand is rebounding, long-term rental activity remains below previous levels, reflecting ongoing challenges in housing availability and affordability.
• Major cities such as Toronto, Vancouver, and Montreal continue to experience some of the steepest rent hikes due to the imbalance between high demand and constrained supply. This is compounded by slower new rental construction and rising costs, which limit the ability to meet the growing needs of renters.
• The rental market dynamics are also influenced by demographic trends, including younger generations’ preference for renting and smaller household sizes, which increase the demand for diverse and flexible rental options.
• Overall, while short-term rental demand shows signs of seasonal strength, the persistent housing shortage and rapid rent increases in Canada’s largest cities underscore the urgent need for expanded rental supply and innovative housing solutions.

Government Regulations

• Canada currently has a temporary Foreign Buyer Ban in effect, which prohibits non-Canadians from purchasing residential properties. This ban, initially set to expire on January 1, 2025, has been extended to January 1, 2027, reflecting ongoing government efforts to address housing affordability and limit speculative foreign investment. The ban applies broadly to individuals and entities that are not Canadian citizens or permanent residents, restricting their ability to buy residential homes in major markets.
• In addition to the federal ban, several provinces and municipalities have introduced property tax surcharges on non-residents. For example, Toronto implemented a 10% tax on residential property purchases by foreign entities starting in 2025, adding to existing provincial non-resident speculation taxes. These measures aim to discourage speculative buying and generate revenue that can support affordable housing initiatives.
• Despite these restrictions, opportunities still exist for newcomers holding valid work or study permits. Temporary residents such as international students, skilled workers, and refugees are generally exempt from the foreign buyer ban, allowing them to purchase residential properties legally. This exemption recognizes the important role of newcomers in Canada’s economy and housing market.
• Moreover, some exemptions apply to properties in smaller or rural communities where housing pressure is lower, and to certain commercial real estate investments. Foreign investors can also explore alternatives like Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) to participate indirectly in the Canadian real estate market.

Key Considerations for Foreigners: Build to Rent vs Buy to Let

For International Students & Workers

• For international students and workers in Canada, the Buy to Let model offers greater entry-level flexibility, making it a practical option for those looking to invest in real estate while residing in the country. Purchasing a condo or smaller residential unit is often more accessible financially and logistically than larger-scale investments, allowing newcomers to enter the housing market with a manageable commitment.
• When considering property purchases, it is advisable to focus on locations near universities, business districts, and public transit hubs. Proximity to educational institutions benefits international students by providing convenient access to classes and campus facilities, while business districts and transit-connected areas appeal to workers seeking easy commutes and vibrant urban amenities. These locations also tend to attract steady rental demand, which can help ensure consistent rental income and potential property appreciation.
• Given the complexities of immigration status and work permits, international students and workers should also be aware of specific regulations and exemptions that may apply to their property ownership rights, ensuring compliance with local laws while maximizing investment opportunities.

For Long-Term Immigrants or High-Net-Worth Individuals 

For long-term immigrants and high-net-worth individuals, the Build to Rent (BTR) model presents an attractive investment opportunity due to its stable income streams and scalable nature. BTR developments are purpose-built rental communities managed professionally, offering consistent rental returns backed by institutional-grade assets. This model reduces the hands-on management burden often associated with smaller rental properties, making it suitable for investors seeking a more passive, long-term approach.

Investors in this category can consider partnering directly with developers involved in BTR projects or investing through real estate trusts, funds, or institutional platforms that specialize in large-scale rental housing. These vehicles provide access to diversified portfolios of rental properties, spreading risk and enhancing potential returns.

Given Canada’s fast-growing industries such as healthcare, technology, engineering, and construction, which attract skilled workers and immigrants, demand for quality rental housing remains strong. Investing in BTR aligns well with these demographic and economic trends, offering both financial stability and growth potential for long-term investors.

Strategic Advice for Newcomers 

Buy to Let is Suitable If You:

• Have limited capital: Buy to Let investments typically require a lower initial outlay compared to large-scale projects like Build to Rent. This makes it an accessible entry point for individual investors or those with smaller budgets. You can start with a single condo, townhouse, or single-family home and gradually build your portfolio over time.
• Want to manage or co-manage a property: If you enjoy being hands-on with your investments, Buy to Let allows you to directly oversee tenant selection, property maintenance, rent collection, and day-to-day operations. Alternatively, you can choose to co-manage the property with a professional letting agent, giving you control while reducing your workload. This flexibility appeals to investors who want to stay involved without fully outsourcing management.
• Are looking for short-term ROI: Buy to Let properties can generate rental income relatively quickly after purchase, providing a steady cash flow. Additionally, in markets with strong demand, there is potential for capital appreciation over a shorter period. This can be advantageous if you aim for quicker returns or plan to sell the property within a few years.
• Prefer flexibility in investment scale: Unlike Build to Rent, where investments are large and tied to entire buildings or complexes, Buy to Let allows you to scale your portfolio incrementally. You can buy one property at a time, diversify across different locations or property types, and adjust your strategy based on market conditions and personal financial goals.
• Want to capitalize on local market knowledge: Buy to Let investors often leverage their understanding of local neighborhoods, school districts, and rental demand to select properties with strong income potential. This localized approach can lead to higher yields if you choose areas with growing populations, good amenities, and strong rental markets.
• Are comfortable with market and tenant risks: Buy to Let investments carry risks such as tenant turnover, vacancy periods, maintenance costs, and fluctuating property values. If you are prepared to manage these risks and navigate landlord responsibilities, this model can offer rewarding financial outcomes.
• Aim to build personal wealth and equity: Over time, mortgage payments reduce your loan balance, increasing your equity in the property. Buy to Let can serve as a long-term wealth-building strategy through both rental income and property appreciation.

Build to Rent is Suitable If You:

• Want passive income with professional management: Build to Rent (BTR) properties are fully managed by dedicated teams that handle all aspects of property operations, including tenant screening, rent collection, maintenance, and legal compliance. This professional management ensures a hassle-free experience for investors, allowing you to enjoy steady rental income without the day-to-day responsibilities of being a landlord.
• Plan long-term investment: BTR developments are designed for stability and consistent cash flow over extended periods. With long-term leases and lower tenant turnover compared to traditional rentals, these properties offer reliable income streams and the potential for steady capital appreciation. This makes BTR an ideal choice for investors focused on building wealth gradually and sustainably.
• Have access to higher capital or joint ventures: Investing in Build to Rent typically requires substantial upfront capital since it involves purchasing entire buildings or large-scale projects. This model is well-suited for high-net-worth individuals, institutional investors, or groups engaging in joint ventures. By pooling resources, investors can access diversified portfolios of professionally managed rental properties, benefiting from economies of scale and reduced risk.
• Seek scalability and portfolio diversification: Build to Rent allows investors to scale their real estate holdings more efficiently by acquiring larger assets rather than individual units. This approach can diversify risk across multiple tenants and units within a single property or portfolio, providing more stable returns compared to owning a few scattered Buy to Let properties.
• Value modern amenities and tenant experience: BTR developments often include attractive amenities such as fitness centers, communal lounges, co-working spaces, and secure parking. These features enhance tenant satisfaction and retention, which in turn supports consistent rental income and reduces vacancy rates. Investing in such properties aligns with evolving renter preferences for lifestyle-oriented living.
• Want to benefit from institutional-grade assets: Build to Rent projects are typically developed with high-quality materials, sustainable building practices, and smart home technologies. This focus on quality not only appeals to tenants but also helps maintain and increase property value over time, offering investors a more secure asset base.
• Prefer a hands-off investment approach: For investors who do not want to be involved in property management or tenant issues, BTR offers a fully passive investment experience. Professional management teams handle all operational challenges, allowing you to focus on other ventures or simply enjoy the income generated.
• Are interested in market trends supporting rental growth: With demographic shifts, urbanization, and changing housing preferences, demand for rental housing continues to rise, especially in major Canadian cities. Build to Rent developments are positioned to meet this demand by providing purpose-built rental communities, making them a forward-looking investment aligned with market needs.

If you're looking to get started, explore our curated selection of rental-ready properties ideal for students, families, and short-term corporate tenants.

Frequently Asked Questions: Build to Rent vs Buy to Let

Can non-residents invest in Canadian real estate?

Yes, non-residents can legally invest in Canadian real estate. There are no citizenship or residency requirements restricting property ownership. However, since 2023, Canada has implemented a temporary two-year ban on foreign buyers purchasing residential properties under the Prohibition on the Purchase of Residential Property by Non-Canadians Act. Certain exemptions apply, including for international students and foreign workers who meet specific criteria, allowing them to buy property despite the ban.

What are the tax implications for foreigners?

Foreign buyers may be subject to additional taxes such as the Foreign Buyers Tax or Non-Resident Speculation Tax (NRST), which can add 15-20% on top of the property’s purchase price in provinces like British Columbia and Ontario. Property taxes also apply annually based on the property's assessed value. International students and certain exempt individuals may qualify for relief from some of these taxes depending on their status and location.

How can international students own or co-own property?

International students can buy property in Canada if they hold a valid study permit and meet certain conditions, such as being enrolled full-time at a designated learning institution and demonstrating intent to settle permanently. They typically need a larger down payment (around 35%) and may face challenges obtaining mortgages due to limited Canadian credit history. Many banks offer mortgage options to international students who can provide proof of income or financial support. Students must also comply with local tax laws and may be exempt from some foreign buyer restrictions.

Is it possible to switch from Buy to Let to Build to Rent later?

While Buy to Let and Build to Rent are distinct investment models, investors can transition from managing individual rental properties (Buy to Let) to participating in or investing in larger-scale Build to Rent projects. This often involves partnering with developers or investing through real estate trusts or funds specializing in Build to Rent. Such a transition typically requires access to higher capital or joint venture opportunities and a shift toward more passive, professionally managed investments.

Conclusion

The key differences between Build to Rent (BTR) and Buy to Let (BTL) revolve around investment scale, management style, risk, and tenant experience. BTR involves larger, institutional-scale investments with professional management, offering stable, long-term income and enhanced tenant amenities. In contrast, BTL allows for smaller, more flexible investments with hands-on or outsourced management, potentially higher but riskier returns, and varied tenant experiences depending on the landlord.

Choosing between BTR and BTL should be tailored to your residency status, available capital, investment goals, and timeline. For newcomers or those with limited capital seeking more control and quicker returns, Buy to Let may be preferable. For long-term immigrants or high-net-worth individuals aiming for passive income and scalable investments, Build to Rent offers a compelling option.

Explore real estate investment solutions in Canada designed for foreigners, start today with Naviliving.